From an Oblique Angle
  • Blog
  • Bigfoot: The Life and Times of a Legend
  • The Fire Ant Wars
  • The Forteans
  • Articles

T. Swann Harding, 1945

9/6/2011

2 Comments

 
“History is the accepted lie.  This is true of scientific as of any other lie; the conventional lie holds.  Every history of scientific discovery we read represents a conventionally accepted fiction which some misguidedly regard as true for all time but which the more intelligent realize is a fiction accepted for convenience.”

how does science progress?  “It can progress only when and because certain patent fictions or lies are universally and conventionally accepted as truth; that temporarily ends controversy in that sector and the synthetic pattern thus create, called scientific truth, does prove useful for many practical purposes.  But cessation of controversy usually occurs because the dispute has exhausted the disputants and nobody is left who cares to waster energy calling anyone else a lawyer.  There are no final truths; there are even no final facts.  There are simply things that appear to be true under certain rigidly controlled conditions and usually some important condition has escaped control.  There are only hypotheses, theories, fiction, and conventional lies.”
                                     From Doubt.

2 Comments
Paul
9/10/2011 11:09:14 am

Gosh . . . did <i>Doubt</i> sparkle like this often, or does one have to rake through a lot of junk to find the gems?

Reply
joshua buhs link
9/12/2011 09:48:30 am

Tiffany Thayer has a bad rap among Forteans, much of it deserved, but I am gaining some appreciation for him, especially his principled stand against the growth of what we now call the military-industrial complex. Having said that, Doubt has 100 pounds of chaff for each grain of wheat.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.
Photo used under Creative Commons from Marcin Wichary